A Day of Gadgets
It took five hours for the five judges to grade the 24 submissions to the App Challenge, which ended February 20. Community developers submitted 12 for Android, four for iPhone, two for Windows 7, one Windows 6.5, and five web applications. The judges and MTD software developers worked side-by-side to navigate through each submission.
“We were there to help the judges understand each platform, assist with any connectivity issues, and reset the apps after they’d been used,” said Ryan Blackman, MTD Software Developer/Network Administrator. Blackman, along with Software Developer Sean Sartell, worked tirelessly for over a year to bring versions one and two of the application programming interface (API) to the public as well as facilitate developer resources.
“When we got the go ahead to do the App Challenge, Ryan and I knew immediately that we could not participate in the judging,” Sartell explained. “We’ve had so many interactions with the developers and we’re close to a few of them. So of course, we’re pretty biased.”
To encourage random app judging, Blackman and Sartell printed individual grading rubrics for each app, shuffled them, and stuffed a folder for each judge. Champaign Telephone Company provided four Android phones, two iPhones, and a Windows Phone 7 to expedite the judging process. Thanks, CTC! MTD staff shared their tablets, for the web applications, and a Windows Mobile 6.5 phone.

From left: Ryan Blackman, Brandon Bowersox-Johnson, Sean Sartell, and Matt Wettersten tally grading rubrics.
As previously announced, the judges panel consisted of three local professionals and two staff members of the MTD.
Brandon Bowersox-Johnson, VP of Technology at Pixo, is involved with research and development for mobile apps and web applications. Bowersox-Johnson was critical of user interfaces and kept an eye on the standards of each operating system. As a multi-decade MTD rider, Bowersox-Johnson is also familiar with MTD’s routes and services. Basically, he was a power house of a judge.
Dr. Kevin Jackson, Assistant Professor of Accountancy at the University of Illinois, brought systematic consistency to the judging. Jackson went through each criterion and gave apps a low, middle, or high ranking accompanied by a plus or minus. Afterward, he placed the score sheet for an app in either a low, middle, or high category among the other submissions. Jackson preferred apps that enabled users to type in an address and then find possible routes and stops.
“For people new to the community, which is always the case at the U of I, they oftentimes just have an address to work with,” Jackson said. “I think it’s useful when apps allow the user to input an address at the start.”
The final outside judge was WCIA Channel 3′s Matt Wettersten. Enthusiasm and aesthetics were Wettersten’s contributions to the judging. By searching major Chambana destinations, he focused on the experience of navigating each app. With a good sportsmanship attitude, Wettersten could never bring himself to score any app with “goose eggs,” as he called them.
MTD’s Director of Market Development, Karl Gnadt, and yours truly, Amy Snyder, Communications Specialist, rounded off the judges panel. Both of us entered common sources of service confusion to see how each app responded and recovered.
“The quantity of the Apps that were submitted exceeded my expectations. More importantly – the quality of the Apps submitted went way beyond my expectations,” Gnadt said.
After much deliberation, a bit of heated discussion, and copious use of the word “subjective,” the judges panel decided to award two first place winners and two third place winners in a dual tie. The first place winners each received $1,000 and the third place winners each got $200.
The Apps
1st Place: Catch MTD by David Grochocki, Phone 7
- Route maps, stop searching, the option to favorite stops, STOPwatch real-time departure information, searching for nearby stops using GPS, trip planning, link to call SafeRides or a taxi, and a feed of MTDnews stories from our website and this blog, The Inside Lane!
1st Place: RideCU by Thomas McGinniss, Android
- Stop searching, favorite stops, STOPwatch, stop searching via GPS, trip planning, and a bus tracker that displays the actual progress of buses for a selected stop.
3rd Place: CU Buses by Benjamin Esham, iOS
- Stop searching, map views, favorite stops, STOPwatch, scheduled time, trip planning with maps as well as detailed origin and destination option including contacts on the user’s phone.
3rd Place: CU Transit by Sukolsak Sakshuwong, iOS
- Views of all maps and schedules, stop searching, detailed map views, STOPwatch, nearby stops via GPS, trip planning, and mapping of trips.
The entire group was a bit bleary eyed by the end, but pleased with the outcome. Get links to download the winning apps and view others submissions to our App Garage.
Which apps have you downloaded? Share a review for one of them!